Himym ending reddit. But now I see something that makes it a lot better.

Himym ending reddit This was an ending that would have been perfect, had the show ended five years ago, just after Ted was left at the altar by Stella. [FanTheories] np. Their chemistry was amazing & they were honestly just so good together. Make him being a great dad at the We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. It's also one of the best episodes altogether. I created a full length finale episode by editing together clips from both parts of "The Last Forever" that ends the show better (no divorce, no death :) One of the reasons I hate that finale is the fact they ruined Barney's character just to make Robin back at Ted. 289K subscribers in the HIMYM community. A subreddit for fans of the show How I Met Your Mother. Most people seem to feel like the entire show was a waste of time when they reached the end of the final season, but I think the ending tied the story together beautifully and makes the entire series more meaningful and thought-out during a re-watch. It’s cool to see the passion you wrote this with My big bugaboo with the ending is simply that it was rushed. However I think that the alternate ending where she doesn't die would have been better. Then season 9 explores some of their I think that season 9 could have been way better if all the episodes had a structure like Gary blauman or rally, or in other words 12 mins of wedding weekend and 8 mins of future content. Life happens, everyone. The title of the show is “How I Met Your Mother” cause that’s what Ted is convincing himself he’s telling the story of. I think they rushed for an ending and thats why Ted and Robin got together. This was the only justifiable way to end How I Met Your Mother. Share Sort by: Best Open comment sort options Add a Comment Popularpressure29 • trueI understand everyone’s frustration at the finale and I felt it myself in 2019 when I watched it for the first time, now my opinion could be slightly different to those who had to watch it season by season or even episode by episode (weekly) during the shows original airing but as someone who watched the final season in a weekend in 2023 I actually get it, knowing the ending when The ending was incredibly polarizing, and people who disliked did so for many different reasons. HIMYM wasn’t afraid to portray real life situations (e. Just saw the last episode for the first time. I don’t understand why people hate season 9? It’s amazing (besides the ending). It was a huge mistake to stretch the wedding out for that entire season and then have them break up in the final episode because it feels meaningless. The episodes are the 207th and 208th overall. Season 9 being Barney and robins wedding would have been way more justified since that was the prime reason they met. It's unbelievably gut-wrenching once you know what happens to Tracy but still hurts like a I've seen it said best on here before, but Barney and Robin's wedding should have been the first half of the final season with the second half focusing on everything we saw in the finale. Besides season 4 it’s the best in my eyes. Instead of letting go of this forced ending and allowing the story to naturally and organically end, they ignored this and resorted to their planned gimmick ending. All the seasons leading up hammer home that the mother is the absolute perfect fit for Ted, then she suddenly dies. I feel like the true message of the ending of how I Met your mother is still not cleared up for many people so here I go Now at the end Ted goes to Robin with the blue French horn and this was seen as Ted going back to Robin after all of these years. I propose a couple The Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp (Let it Roll) by George Harrison played in Season 6 Episodes 1 and 24 Prophets by AC Newman played in the Season 4 Finale Lifesize by A Fine Frenzy played in the Season 5 Finale Mother of Pearl by Roxy Music played in Season 1 Episode 21 I'm Gonna Be (500 Miles) by 278K subscribers in the HIMYM community. My story is rather unique. I think that since they filmed the ending way back when the show started (they made the kids sign NDAs and everything) they felt “forced” into using the Ted and Robin ending. And if anyone complains that 12 minutes is too long, be thankful I didn't make you watch the entire 1-hour analysis video haha 😅 (though I do Reddit discussion threads for How I Met Your Mother You end up having a VERY active fantasy life and talking about sex more freely just to fight the constant assumptions that you're a prude. ” Barney’s arc/ character development goes out the window. Jan 6, 2025 · The ending to HIMYM is often called one of the worst endings to a TV sitcom. He even knew how to truly love a woman and got into serious relationships in 3 occasions. That's the theme; that's what they were driving home in the last hour: Life happens and it's how you deal with it while finding . This doesn’t mean the TMs didn’t love each other dearly, but Robin was Teds The reason I liked the ending was because it was so counterproductive- it was so confusing and illogical and made no sense. com Open Hi, There's obviously a lot of grief about the ending right now. Reply reply more replies more replies More replies [deleted] • Comment deleted by user Reply reply dasfiddler • “how I met your mother then went back to Robin after several seasons and episodes showing why Robin and I don’t work”. be Open Share Add a Comment Sort by: Best Open comment sort options Best Top New Controversial Old Q&A stryker101 • My HIMYM ending: Barney and Robin get married in a two-parter at the start of season 9. The writers just threw away years of character development Throughout seasons we learned that Barney had more deph that a simple misogynist who could not care about women. They were downvoted and told it was nonsense. r/HIMYM: A subreddit for fans of the show How I Met Your Mother. There was very little screen time for the I am a HUGE non-believer in the mother is dead theory. reddit. I’ve seen so many criticisms of the ending that the mother was barely even featured…but Ted’s relationship with the mother was never the Jan 10, 2025 · Revisiting the controversial How I Met Your Mother ending: Who Ted ends up with — and why the finale deserves more love Haaaave you met the mother? Apr 11, 2025 · Years after the beloved sitcom came to an end, we're now wondering: what if the controversial How I Met Your Mother finale was good, actually? Nov 12, 2025 · Upon finishing How I Met Your Mother, I had learned two things: “Nothing good happens after 2 a. What was the fan reaction to this twist? Was it received positively or negatively? Did people feel like it made the entire Quinn storyline a waste of time? Did people like that Barney and Robin were gonna end up 162 votes, 88 comments. That’s why the story ends when they meet and we rush through all the rest afterwards that the kids, im sure, already know about. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Discussion of, and media… Seriously. 1. Ted meeting the Mother would have been the perfect ending (I am an alternative ending supporter). I got the ending I wanted, in most ways, and the one I had been predicting for a couple of years so I was already at peace with the fact Am I the only one crying at the ending because I’m so happy they end up together? I’m so moved and feel really alone in this opinion. But in the 6 seasons that occurred between then and now, all of the characters developed in ways that made this ending no longer the right fit for the show. Unpopular opinion: the ending was perfect. The reason being, this was an ending that completely disregarded and betrayed the last five years of the characters' growth. So make him simply go We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. And the idea of the entire show is that the audience knows that he gets his happily ever after with the Barney and Robin also would not have worked in the real world. g. 17M subscribers in the television community. The (much better) alternate ending to How I Met Your Mother. Congrats on winning the most accurate summation of the feelings of the entire r/HIMYM community following this finale award. I get that Barney and robin divorce was pretty quick but the ending with Ted and robin basically brings the show full circle. 9K votes, 697 comments. Ted and Robin had to end up together? The story is literally called How I met your mother. They simply wasted too much time and too many scenes on the other characters and nonsensical potty humor, all season, when they could have allowed the Mother (Tracy) to have some time with Ted, so that everyone felt that they had some Feb 12, 2025 · i personally liked the ending, it concluded every characters arc, ted ending up with robin, barney finally getting a responsibility, and marshall Nov 28, 2024 · How I Met Your Mother: The Controversial Ending Explained When the popular TV show How I Met Your Mother (HIMYM) concluded in 2014, fans were left reeling with a finale that sparked a lot of debate. Wasnt the ending already decided from season 1? All of the recording of the kids is from season 1 because as the show goes on the kids would age but that wouldnt make sense since the kids were hearing the story in one sitting. 269K subscribers in the HIMYM community. HIMYM is literally my comfort show I’ve watched it all the way through probably 40+ times if not more. Time Travelers is sad no matter which way you look at it. ‘How I Met Your Mother’: 10 Years Later, Does the Series Finale Still Not Work? indiewire. MembersOnline • [deleted] ADMIN MOD Just finished watching the show for the first time, cried, browsed this sub for an hour to cope - i'm not the first or last one. Most of them revolve around the following: Barney and Robin's divorce, the reversal of character development, the Mother's death, and perhaps most important of all, Ted and Robin reuniting in 2030. I’ve seen so many criticisms of the ending that the mother was barely even featured…but Ted’s relationship with the mother was never the point. With HIMYM they just flat out disrespected their fans by turning against everything they stated. 2. MembersOnline • sggrant323 HIMYM has so much deeper symbolism subtly placed in every episode which is neglected because of the hate on The Ending & Season 9 The Ending is Perfect but you're not ready to have the conversation yet (not enough dedicated rewatches) Misinterpretation lead to disappointment. Discussion of, and media from anything How I Met… I have watched HIMYM about 6 times all together (it's my all time favourite show) and I still, to this day, think Barney and Robin should have been end game. If HIMYM had ended after season 1 or 2, even season 3, I think this ending would have worked. I’m extremely curious to see what the consensus is about the How I Met Your Mother ending all these years later. They spend an entire season on a wedding and the marriage lasted for minutes. The show is called how I met your mother. I know she's going to hate the official ending because every time Ted and Robin have gotten back together, after S1, she legitimately screams "NO!" 😂 I laid out 2 options: Simply just watch the last episode like normal, or Experience the alternate ending with the show, first, simply because "I'd Nov 18, 2019 · How I Met Your Mother’s series finale stirred up some serious controversy, so we're here to tell you why HIMYM's grand finish felt like a disappointment. These puzzle pieces only fall into trueObviously spoilers for the episode (and the whole show) In the S7 finale, Barney proposes to Quinn, but in the flash forward, they reveal that Barney actually marries Robin. Why is the ending so controversial and hated Ok I just finished watching himym today and I genuinely don’t understand y ppl hate this ending so much. Share Sort by: Best Open comment sort options Best Top New Controversial Old Q&A Add a Comment ElCidly • A subreddit for fans of the show How I Met Your Mother. The people that complained about the ending definitely didn't see the entire series; they watched the last episode (or a few episodes here and there) and are mistaken about the ending. 291K subscribers in the HIMYM community. I liked the ending, it made sense, many things in the life of Ted led him to the point of accepting that it wasn't his time to be with Robin, the time was right for him and Tracy to find happiness after their hearts had been broken and have a life of love. Season nine made up for how infuriated I was with season 8. The story ending with Ted ending up with Robin makes sense to me because it justified why the story started on the night he met Robin, long before he met Tracy. ” and the ending is controversial. The show, which premiered in 2005, had captured the hearts of millions with its witty humor, lovable characters, and unique narrative structure. Let's start the definitive playlist of the best How I Met Your Mother songs. I’ve seen so many posts that hate the ending, and with all art, their opinion is valid… I just tend to disagree as I find the finale to be one of my favorite episodes. Like many others, I had been disturbed when I originally watched the series finale. I was ok with Barney and Robin divorcing as it felt natural to have this constant struggle between career and personal life continue for Robin. Here are 5 things fans loved & hated about it. Once they got the happy ending they initially wanted individually, they could get the happy ending they wanted as a couple. 294K subscribers in the HIMYM community. ) The show personally devoted way too much screentime to hinting at the future to fuck the ending up that bad. Unfortunately, the show set up, and thus made viewers incredibly invested in, Barney and Robin's relationship. I've compiled all the main points into a short 12-minute video. It was a slap in the face. Don’t get me wrong, I do have my issues with it, but Ted and Robin eventually getting together is certainly not one of them. This actually sums up the entire show. For me the whole nonsense Robin + Ted thing wasn't the worst of the finale. But it isn't. Firstly, there was some pretty heavy foreshadowing of the ending as Tracy’s ‘love her of her life’ had died, making Ted her second choice. (If you don’t care, don’t read. Barney's ending was. Personally HIMYM ending makes sense, why you may ask? Well, first of all, HIMYM is a show about future Ted telling his children how he met his mother, and he didn't start the story before he met his mother, he started it before he met Robin, not Marshall, not Lily, not Barney, But he started before he met Robin. r/HIMYF: How I Met Your Father is an American Comedy Sit-Com Television Series, and a spin-off of the 2005 TV Series How I Met Your Mother. 290K subscribers in the HIMYM community. By keeping it to two episodes, the pacing improves a lot. “Sophie… Upon further review and thought- the concept of the Mother dying is not the problem I had with the end. ELI5: What is the deal with the "How I Met Your Mother" ending controversy? I have never once seen the show in my life but I keep hearing people say the ending was so bad and discussing it for hundreds and hundreds of comments. Through the seasons, we see Barney go from a womanizer to a more mature guy willing to compromise and have a long relationship with one person. The show's unique storytelling concept and early finale planning left little room for adaptation and character evolution, causing controversy 6K votes, 263 comments. Basically, the mother lives and the Robin ending is cut out, with the show ending on: Ted: And that's how I met your mother. Ted spends the entire 9 seasons wallowing in his loneliness and counting on one day meeting the one. Idfc if you all May 28, 2020 · The finale of How I Met Your Mother is one of the most divisive in recent television history. Now we’ve had proper time to calm down a little, rewatch the show a couple dozen times and hear what the cast and crew have to say, what’s your opinion on the ending of the show? HIMYM Ending I just wanted to get on here and talk about/express my feelings about the ending cause I have no friends that have watched so I have to keep it bottled up lol. Despite how many losses the show suffered from behind-the-scenes in its final few seasons, its crazy to me that it delivered a more gut wrenching, emotionally-filled series finale than How I Met Your Mother, which (from my understanding) didn't face any of the same production problems, cast exits, and budget cuts that Community had. I think the writers just botched the way they did it. Imagine if slapsgiving 3 was framed at ted and the mothers first thanksgiving together, or if last time in new York had a 5 min cutaway to ted and tracy's first time in their new house, and perhaps if sunrise 506 votes, 172 comments. There are some times in which sad endings are needed, but I wouldn't say this was one of these times. So being rather bored, I ended up watching the end of How I Met Your Mother. Can we actually discuss both things that point to and away from the theory? For example, my biggest one is that in the college reunion scene, Ted is high and jokingly says It’s insane that just a couple of edits changes an abysmal ending to an awesome ending. 6K votes, 212 comments. I think they basically should've ended it right after the Tracy section. The ending of show continues that theme. Why do people criticized season 9? HIMYM was never about meeting the mother of the kids he was talking about. Marshall’s Dad passing away) & that’s one of the many reasons it’s so great. trueHow to watch the alternate ending at the end of the show instead of the official ending? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I'm currently watching the series with my girlfriend and we're finally on the last season. They showed tons of reasons why throughout the show. I don't think the writers could have possibly come up with a better ending. The premise of the show revolves around Ted Mosby retelling the story of his life and past relationships to his children, leading up to the moment that he meets his wife, their mother. Almost 2 years ago, u/Pointing_Out_Irony accurately predicted the ending of How I Met Your Mother. Jul 3, 2024 · HIMYM's ending was criticized for undoing characters' arcs and minimizing the awaited first meeting of Ted and the Mother, instead reuniting Ted with Robin. Please people who love the ending, tell me why and let’s talk. And it made sense that the two got together now. Discussion of, and media from anything How I Met… A subreddit for fans of the show How I Met Your Mother. The biggest problem with the ending, for me, is that it was five years too late. After tonight's episode and reading the discussion thread though, I'm buying further into it. com 0 74 Share Add a Comment By season three, I knew the story had nothing to do with the mother. m. I truly think it was brilliant and I loved it all (except season 8). After a couple years since it's ended how do you feel about this show/finale now? youtu. They didn't need to force things in order to surprise us. It's everything that HIMYM is about; enjoying stupid moments with your friends and partly wishing they'd last forever, simply because you don't know what you have to do after those moments are gone. Season 8 was awful. 300K subscribers in the HIMYM community. Then, Ted meets Tracy off-screen and we don't get to see it. Discussion of, and media… "Last Forever" Parts 1 and 2 are the 23rd and 24th and final episodes of the ninth season of the American sitcom television series How I Met Your Mother and the series finale of the show as a whole. Also I think Lily's definitely bisexual. their biggest screw up was deciding that the final season would entirely take place at their wedding. I still loved the show despite the ending, but for the past few years I've basically rewritten the alternate ending as cannon in my brain. The scene with Victoria where she says “I hope you get her someday” is such beautifully done scene. 56 votes, 25 comments. ” Robin and Barney made so much sense together; they were both fiery and strong individuals Ted and 1. Discussion of, and media… This "Why HIMYM Is Better Than Friends" analysis video by Kross perfectly encapsulates my feelings for HIMYM's alternate ending, it's said even better than I could ever explain it. Discussion of, and media… A subreddit for fans of the show How I Met Your Mother. Discussion of, and media from anything How I Met Your Mother related. 7K votes, 164 comments. The final episode of himym is highly controversial because Tracy ends up not being the final mother. The fact that the individuals who played Ted’s kids not only filmed the ending of the show within the first 2 seasons, but then had to keep that ending a secret for nearly a decade is still one of the craziest pieces of HIMYM trivia that I feel doesn’t get talked about enough. But that was exactly the point. Misdirection would be the mother dying, but Ted ending up with Robin is just down right garbage from a writing perspective. When ted gives his big speech to Robin about love in season9 - he loudly proclaims “love doesn’t have to make sense… to make sense. I understand why people have this sentiment but I just blatantly Nope, I’m right there with you!! I think the ending is ingenious, in fact the end’s one of the things that makes HIMYM my Top 1 comedy show of all time. Your post is very thorough & offers a take not many have. ) Bittersweet Ending [No Robin/Death] A simple twist on the ending of HIMYM, this is the alternate ending with minimal edits. But I still think the ending was incredible and that its a huge over exaggeration to say it ruined the show. The only part about the ending I didn't like was Ted getting with Robin. HIMYM was a show about life. People saying they've ruined the show, it's all pointless, etc. It originally aired in the United States on CBS We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Kids: That's it? Ted: That's it. I get that the writers had the ending already in mind since season one but personally I think that HIMYM evolved and the official ending didn't fit where it the show ended up. The last moments of season 1 are possibly my favourite from the show : r/HIMYM r/HIMYM Current search is within r/HIMYM Remove r/HIMYM filter and expand search to all of Reddit We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. But now I see something that makes it a lot better. I tried to read some but the plot seems very thick and convoluted. Thinking about it, though, I keep switching my opinion back and forth. The episode was written by series creators Carter Bays and Craig Thomas and directed by Pamela Fryman. Discussion of, and media… It frames the whole show as Ted justifying to his kids banging Robin, rather than actually “how I met your mother. His kids deconstruct that in the last episodes. While i agree that the final season and the ending are a bit messy, i resonate with the foreshadowing in season 8 about the 45 days or seconds and in season 9 about Tracy saying which mother is gonna miss their daughters wedding. I’ve recently been rewatching the show (currently on Season 8), and it’s making me appreciate the ending more. tkswn kvznf ihksxjwk xrzyd qumom lzk nfcvvh wkuwcrd ogv iuncs wvirz lhsqd syouedt dmkc puexbp